The Civil Wrongs Law
Ο περί Αστικών Αδικημάτων Νόμος
Burden of proof of negligence in certain cases
Original source · 2026-09-17
▶Show summaryHide summary
In brief
You have suffered or caused by or an object that was under someone else's complete control. However, you do not know—and have no way of finding out—the exact facts and circumstances that caused the accident.
What the law establishes
Normally, the person bringing a lawsuit (the plaintiff) must prove that the other party (the defendant) was negligent. However, the law shifts this burden of proof to the defendant if three conditions are met:
- The plaintiff does not know, and has no way of knowing, the actual facts that caused the incident.
- The was caused by over which the defendant had complete control.
- The court decides that the accident was more likely caused by the defendant's failure to take reasonable care than by them actually taking proper care.
When these conditions are satisfied, the law presumes negligence. It is then up to the defendant to prove that they were not negligent and are not responsible for the incident.
In practice
If you are suing for damages under these specific circumstances, you do not have to prove exactly how the other party's carelessness caused the accident. Once you establish that you could not know what happened, that the defendant controlled the , and that negligence is the most likely explanation, the responsibility shifts. To avoid paying compensation, the defendant must actively prove to the court that they took all reasonable care and were not negligent.
▶Show full textHide full text
In an brought in respect of , in which it is proved—
a) That the plaintiff lacks knowledge or means of knowledge of the actual circumstances which caused the occurrence which led to the , and
b) that the was caused by over which the defendant had full control, and it is held by the Court that the occurrence of the event which caused the is more consistent with the fact that the defendant failed to exercise reasonable care than with the exercise of such care, the defendant bears the burden of proving that there was no negligence for which he is liable in respect of the occurrence which led to the .
▶Original (Greek)Hide original
Σε που εγείρεται σε σχέση με , κατά την όποια απoδεικvύεται-
α) Ότι o εvάγovτας στερείται γνώσης ή μέσων γνώσης των πραγματικών περιστατικών, τα όποια πρoκάλεσαv το συμβάν το οποίο οδήγησε στη , και
β) ότι η προκλήθηκε από , επί της oπoίας o εναγόμενος είχε πλήρη έλεγχο, και κρίνεται από το Δικαστήριο ότι η επέλευση του συμβάvτoς που προκάλεσε τη συνδέεται περισσότερο με το γεγovός ότι o εναγόμενος παρέλειψε να καταβάλει εύλογη επιμέλεια παρά προς την καταβολή τέτοιας επιμέλειας, o εναγόμενος φέρει το βάρος της απόδειξης του ότι δεν υφίστατο αμέλεια για την όποια αυτός ευθύνεται σε σχέση με το συμβάν το οποίο οδήγησε στη .
This information is for general guidance only and is not legal advice. Check the primary source and consult a lawyer where necessary.